The "Good" Teacher

November 7, 2015

Every year during district and region audition season, I second-guess myself as a teacher.  It's rather comical that the cycle is so predictable, yet it never seems to lose momentum.  The pattern goes something like this:


1. I coach etudes ad nauseam

2. I preach the importance of slow, methodical practice

3. I meticulously scrutinize minutia so students can hear at a deeper level


4. I host a mock-audition to get kids used to the intense audition environment

5. My kids go off to their auditions


I'm rarely surprised at the results of auditions.  (Most of the time, I can anticipate a student's trajectory within five minutes of their very first lesson.)  I know which of my students get nervous and which ones thrive under the pressure of performance.  I know their sweet little idiosyncrasies better than they do.  And yet, though it is entirely out of my control and I do EVERYTHING in my power to prepare them (from making practice plans to writing specific weekly goals), I worry for them.


Although it may sound cheesy and self-gratifying, I am constantly evaluating my efficacy as a teacher. My students' binder, a curriculum I am constantly modifying and adding to despite the fact that it works very well, is a small testament to that.  How is it, then, that confidence from years of wonderful students making beautiful music manages to shrivel to self-deprecation every November?  The struggle boils down to this question: am I a good teacher?


Instead of fighting the struggle, I am learning to embrace it.  It would be a disservice to my students if I didn't care so much about their well-being as saxophonists (and even deeper, as PEOPLE).  If I just let every audition go by without asking myself "what can I do better next time", I wouldn't grow.  If I didn't sit down with each student after their audition, go through it with them, praise them for all their hard work, make a list of new goals, and dive in to the next adventure, I would be doing our field a great disservice.  


Without the ability and willingness to improve, there is no such thing as a "good" teacher.  Perhaps, then, a "good" teacher is one who is willing to grow and learn with AND from her students.  


Please reload

Recent Posts

March 14, 2020

November 3, 2019

April 2, 2019

January 3, 2019

September 13, 2018

Please reload

© 2012-20 Elizabeth Rosinbum

Saxophone Lessons Austin, saxophone teacher Austin
  • Facebook App Icon
  • Twitter App Icon
  • LinkedIn App Icon